Tunnels under hospitals and other protected sites are unproven

CLAIM:

Tunnels under hospitals and other protected sites are unproven.

STATUS:

Misleading

KEY COUNTERPOINTS:

The claim is flatly false for at least two major sites where independent journalists physically entered the tunnels and reported what they found. At Al-Shifa Hospital in November 2023, CNN’s Oren Liebermann entered the tunnel shaft within the hospital compound and reported on-site: “It does not establish without a doubt that there is a command center, but it is clear that there is a tunnel down below.” AP and Fox reporters also entered independently. At UNRWA’s Gaza headquarters in February 2024, AP, Reuters, NPR (Greg Myre), and CBC reporters physically walked through a tunnel the IDF exposed beneath the compound. AP reported the tunnel “stretched for at least half a kilometer, with at least 10 doors” and confirmed “at least a portion of the tunnel ran underneath the facility’s courtyard.” UNRWA Commissioner-General Philippe Lazzarini stated UNRWA “did not know what is under its headquarters in Gaza.” These are not Israeli claims. They are first-hand accounts by independent journalists who were inside the tunnels.
The Al-Shifa case is independently corroborated by U.S. government intelligence, not just by Israeli announcements. AP reported in January 2024 that a declassified U.S. intelligence assessment concluded Hamas and PIJ used Al-Shifa and the sites beneath it to hold at least a few hostages and house command infrastructure. White House NSC spokesman John Kirby stated prior to the operation: “We have our own intelligence that convinces us that Hamas was using Al-Shifa as a command and control node, and most likely as well as a storage facility.” Reuters separately reported that the White House said it had evidence Hamas was using Al-Shifa to run military operations. U.S. intelligence and Israeli military claims independently converging on the same site is significantly stronger than either source alone.
The correct rebuttal to the claim is not that tunnels are proven everywhere, but that the evidence is deeply uneven across sites — ranging from independently corroborated to actively disproven — and that “unproven” is therefore too absolute a characterization. OHCHR’s December 2024 thematic hospital report explicitly distinguishes between Al-Shifa, where Israel provided the most substantial public evidence, and other hospitals including Hamad, Al-Quds, Indonesian, and Nasser, where public substantiation remained insufficient. One IDF facility-use claim — a tunnel under the Qatari Hospital (8 November 2023) — was actively disproven by Al Jazeera’s Sanad verification unit. The honest framework acknowledges all three tiers: corroborated, unverified, and in one case debunked.
Even setting tunnel evidence aside, non-Israeli sources independently documented armed actor presence inside Gaza hospitals during the current conflict. MSF announced in February 2026 that it suspended noncritical operations at Nasser Hospital, citing “the presence of armed men, intimidation, arbitrary arrests of patients, and a recent situation of suspicion of movement of weapons.” MSF stated it “was not able to indicate the armed men’s affiliation.” That is the only independent humanitarian organization to document armed presence inside a functioning Gaza hospital. It does not retroactively prove tunnel claims during the 2023-24 raids, but it directly defeats the premise that Gaza hospitals were exclusively civilian in character throughout the conflict.

EVIDENCE:

CNN reporters Oren Liebermann and Nic Robertson personally entered the Al-Shifa tunnel shaft in November 2023. Liebermann’s on-site report: “It does not establish without a doubt that there is a command center, but it is clear that there is a tunnel down below.”
AP, Reuters, NPR (Greg Myre), and CBC reporters physically walked through the tunnel beneath UNRWA’s Gaza headquarters in February 2024. AP confirmed at least part ran under the UNRWA courtyard; the tunnel “stretched for at least half a kilometer, with at least 10 doors.”
UNRWA Commissioner-General Lazzarini confirmed UNRWA “did not know what is under its headquarters in Gaza.”
Declassified U.S. intelligence (January 2024, reported by AP): Hamas and PIJ used Al-Shifa and sites beneath it for command functions and to hold at least a few hostages.
White House NSC spokesman John Kirby, prior to the November 2023 Al-Shifa operation: confirmed U.S. intelligence indicated Hamas was using Al-Shifa as a command and control node and likely for storage.
OHCHR December 2024: Al-Shifa received the most public substantiation; Hamad, Al-Quds, Indonesian, and Nasser hospital allegations remained insufficiently substantiated in public.
Al Jazeera Sanad verification unit (8 November 2023): actively disproved a specific IDF tunnel claim at the Qatari Hospital. Established that some IDF facility-use claims have been independently debunked.
MSF (February 2026): suspended noncritical operations at Nasser Hospital citing armed men, patient intimidation, arbitrary arrests, and suspicion of weapons movement. Independent, non-Israeli.

PRIMARY SOURCES:

CNN — “CNN visited the exposed tunnel shaft in the Al-Shifa Hospital compound. Here’s what we saw” (20 Nov 2023)
https://edition.cnn.com/2023/11/20/middleeast/gaza-tunnel-shaft-al-shifa-hospital-intl-hnk/index.html
CNN’s Oren Liebermann personally entered the Al-Shifa tunnel. The strongest independent media confirmation of the tunnel’s existence within the compound. Quote: “It does not establish without a doubt that there is a command center, but it is clear that there is a tunnel down below.” Not an Israeli source.

↑↑↑ Best source!

AP News — “U.S. intel confident militant groups used largest Gaza hospital in campaign against Israel”
https://apnews.com/article/hamas-intelligence-shifa-biden-hostages-israel-d0f782682a7a06ed5a3749ed92c4f821 Declassified U.S. intelligence confirming Hamas and PIJ command use of Al-Shifa and sites beneath it, including hostage-holding. U.S. government corroboration independent of Israeli military claims.

↑↑↑ best source!

AP News — “Israel reveals signs of Hamas activity at Shifa, but a promised command center remains elusive”
https://apnews.com/article/israel-hamas-war-gaza-shifa-hospitals-a017ba154c816c8d565393917dadd9ee Independent reporting on what was actually shown at Al-Shifa: tunnel, weapons, and the important limits on the “vast command center” framing. Essential for calibrating the claim correctly — corroborates the tunnel while maintaining honesty about what was not proven.

↑↑↑ best source!

NPR — Greg Myre, reporting from inside the UNRWA HQ tunnel (February 2024) https://www.npr.org/2024/02/10/1230632741/israel-gaza-tunnels-unrwa-united-nations
Independent journalist first-hand account from inside the UNRWA headquarters tunnel. Independently corroborates Reuters and AP on the UNRWA case.

↑↑↑ best source!

Reuters — “Hamas had command tunnel under UN Gaza HQ, Israel says” (10 Feb 2024) https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/hamas-had-command-tunnel-under-un-gaza-hq-israeli-military-says-2024-02-10/
Journalists physically present in the UNRWA HQ tunnel. Records both the Israeli allegation and UNRWA’s position that it did not know what was beneath the building.

↑↑↑ best source!

Reuters — “White House says it has evidence Hamas using Al Shifa hospital to run military actions” (14 Nov 2023)
https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/white-house-says-it-has-evidence-hamas-using-al-shifa-hospital-run-military-2023-11-14/
White House publicly backing U.S. intelligence on Hamas use of Al-Shifa before the ground operation. Pre-operation corroboration independent of the post-raid IDF announcements.

↑↑↑ best source!

OHCHR, Thematic Report: Attacks on hospitals (31 December 2024) https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/documents/countries/opt/20241231-attacks-hospitals-gaza-en.pdf Critical guardrail source. Confirms the uneven evidentiary situation: Al-Shifa most substantiated; several other hospitals insufficiently documented. Prevents overgeneralization of the corroborated cases to all sites.

↑↑↑ worst source! 😭

STRONGEST COUNTER ARGUMENTS WORTH KNOWING:

The evidence for Al-Shifa and UNRWA headquarters is strong and independently corroborated. The evidence for most other hospitals is weak, largely Israeli-sourced, and OHCHR said so explicitly. Critics can correctly argue that the strongest cases should not be used to validate weaker claims about Nasser, Al-Quds, Indonesian, Hamad, or other hospitals.
AP itself reported that the broadest early public claim — a “vast multi-level Hamas command center” under Al-Shifa — was not established by what was shown to reporters. The tunnel exists. The early IDF command-center framing overreached. Acknowledging that openly makes the note stronger, not weaker.
Al Jazeera Sanad disproved the Qatari Hospital tunnel claim. That is a legitimate precedent: IDF facility-use announcements require independent verification and should not be accepted wholesale. It does not destroy the Al-Shifa or UNRWA HQ cases, but it should discipline the wording applied to other sites.
Much of the detailed post-Al-Shifa material (Kamal Adwan weapons-in-incubators claims, Nasser hostage medication) came from managed Israeli embeds, officially released detainee videos, or IDF photographs. AP, CNN, and NYT explicitly declined to verify those specific claims independently. They should be labeled Israeli-sourced at Tier C, not treated as independently proven.

NOTES:

Do not say tunnels are either fully proven or wholly unproven. Both formulations are weak and both are easy to attack.

The correct evidentiary framework is tiered:

Independently corroborated (journalists + U.S. intelligence): Al-Shifa tunnel, UNRWA HQ tunnel
Partially corroborated or managed-embed only: Al-Rantisi basement and weapons finds
Israeli-sourced, unverified by independent media: most mosque-weapons claims, Kamal Adwan
Actively disproven: Qatari Hospital (Al Jazeera Sanad, 8 November 2023)

The Qatari Hospital disproof is the honest concession that must be made in debate. Acknowledge it directly: “One specific IDF tunnel claim was independently debunked. That does not affect the Al-Shifa or UNRWA HQ cases, which were physically confirmed by multiple independent journalists.” Conceding the weak case makes the strong cases more credible.

The strongest single-sentence formulation for debate: Tunnels under Al-Shifa Hospital and UNRWA headquarters were physically entered and confirmed by independent journalists from CNN, AP, NPR, and CBC, and corroborated by declassified U.S. intelligence. Claims at most other sites remain unverified or insufficiently substantiated, and at least one IDF site-specific claim was actively disproven by independent fact-checking.

**see more:

COGAT assessment, Medical responses for the Gaza Strip.pdf
Hamas War Crimes Harm Palestinians and Israelis Alike.pdf
Hamas-Israel Conflict 2023, Key Legal Aspects.pdf
Hamas’ use of human shields in Gaza.pdf
Israel-Hamas Conflict 2023, Humanitarian Efforts.pdf
ISRAEL’S INITIAL COMMENTS TO OHCHR 4th THEMATIC REPORT.pdf

Explorer

Tunnels under hospitals and other protected sites are unproven

CLAIM:

STATUS:

KEY COUNTERPOINTS:

EVIDENCE:

PRIMARY SOURCES:

STRONGEST COUNTER ARGUMENTS WORTH KNOWING:

NOTES:

Graph View

Table of Contents

Backlinks